As I m
entioned in my last post, I’ve been following the preparations for Victoria Snaith’s Dread Falls Theatre production of “Father Dagon”, an H.P. Lovecraft-inspired, immersive multidisciplinary storytelling theatrical event. I took some shots at the dress rehearsal a couple of Sundays ago, and on the next Wednesday evening at 7pm, attended the first night’s opening performance.
I will say at the outset that I felt that it would be difficult for me to give an unbiased, impartial or objective review, for the following, conflicting reasons:
1) I have been in touch with Victoria, and Will Connor, DFT’s musical director, for several weeks leading up to the event, and so have had access to rehearsal schedules, news on progress (both breakthroughs and challenges), and some idea of the characters that would be portrayed in the production. I felt invested in the whole project, and could almost double-guess what the spectacle would be (how wrong I was!).
2) I have long been a reader and fan of Lovecraft’s canon of work, and that of his contemporaries and others that followed later, creating what is now known as the Cthulhu or Lovecraftian mythos. I am particularly familiar with the two stories that this production would draw its inspiration from, “Dagon” and “The Shadow over Innsmouth”. I imagined, in my naivety, that this foreknowledge would hold me in good stead in understanding the unfolding experience. Fool.
3) I’m not really into all this experimental immersive dancing and music stuff, I’m more of a linear visual and narrative guy (this possibly explains why I’m a photographer, artist and writer). Theatre, acting, dance, music, video, and film are all wonderful nouns. Immersive, experimental, alternative, expressive, conceptual, modern and contemporary are beautiful adjectives too. But in my book, the two sets of words should never, *ever* be combined. I was therefore doomed from the start – and points 1) and 2) were effectively negated. What horror had I let myself in for? As Lovecraft himself said, and which was the strapline for the production itself: “The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown.” But then again, running these concepts all together in a Lovecraftian context, maybe this might work…
I wasn’t terribly reassured by the dress rehearsal, which was held in an open-plan school gymnasiu
m in West London, selected because its dimensional footprint matched that of the actual venue. Without the dividing walls between performance areas (masking tape had been laid on the floor to guide the actors), it was a confusing sight, with actors and dancers apparently moving around randomly, some talking, some muttering to themselves, others dancing, or fighting, and over all this the strange, discordant, improvised and pre-recorded noises that would accompany the performances. Power, comms and pickup cables snaked across the floor connecting islands of random objects, some of which resembled
a beachcomber’s collection (Andrew Page – raxil4‘s stringed instrument, left), while Anton Mobin‘s decks looked like a strange blend of crystal radio set, Victorian flea circus, and wartime Enigma cipher machine. Will Connor (Seesar), stranded in New York, was coordinating the musical effort remotely, having pre-recorded his acoustic elements. Surrounded by this demented carousel, Victoria Snaith directed, banging out the tempo on the polished wooden floor with a stout cane. After an hour, my assistant (eldest son) and I exchanged a wordless glance, and packed away our photographic equipment.
But enough of this ennui of caveats and misgivings: let’s get on with this attempt at an objective review of the opening night’s early performance:
After a qu
ick reviver at the “Pride of Spitalfields”, I wandered down to the “Rag Factory”, a now-disused textile warehouse just off Brick Lane in East London. I’m familiar with it from previous events (Models of Diversity’s “THE FЯONT ROW”), and therefore was prepared for the grimy, run-down look of the cobbled entrance to this old, Victorian-era sweatshop (very apposite for the subject matter). What I hadn’t expected was the newly-added tables and benches outside, and the pagoda tents to protect drinkers and smokers from the elements. The glass-fronted foyer was inviting, with a well-appointed bar with friendly staff. The walls were hung with suitably-themed photographic and art prints – all for sale. It’s just a shame that the promised Cthulhu- and Dagon-themed sculptures and artifacts were not available – would you believe it, they’d been seized inbound at Customs on suspicion of being illegally-looted ancient Mayan or Aztec archaeological treasures! That our Customs officers wouldn’t recognise cast resin from ancient stone doesn’t surprise me, but it helped with the Lovecraftian conspiracy theories, especially when you consider that Will Connor, musical director and erstwhile performer, was still stranded in New York, unable to get a visa for travel back to the UK for the performances.
A bell announced the beginning of the show, and after a brief prologue by the narrator/novelist, the audience were invited to enter the performance area. This was divided into rooms separated either by solid walls, partitions, or black drapes, and I recognised the designations from the masking-taped gym floor: there was the novelist’s study, there the old church (now the Temple of the Esoteric Order of Dagon), over here a room in a house in benighted Innsmouth, and beyond, the quay or dockside. Interconnecting these sets, or performance areas, was a maze constructed from torn strips of black drapery – representing, I think, the maze of alleys in the old town.
The audience were encouraged to follow a character, or characters, of their choice as the story unfolded. There were at least three story arcs, which each looped three times, before they all converged on the finale. The idea was that you could switch from arc to arc and see the story from each perspective, although as I can clearly remember seeing one scene three times, I must have missed another entirely!
It is true that there was less narrative storytelling than I am used to, but that is possibly no bad thing, as the intention was obviously to create a disturbing confusion in the audience, a sense of disquiet and apprehension. It certainly achieved that effect. Lovecraft himself rarely described his horrors blatantly, prefering to hint at them, suggesting rather than revealing – his works are peppered with stock references to “remote secrets and unimaginable abysses in time and space”, and “unknown and inhuman evil”. He reserved his incredibly-detailed prose descriptions for scene-setting and architecture in particular – I don’t think I’ve read any of his stories that didn’t fit in some description of a gambrel roof or a gable! Director Victoria Snaith instead positioned visual clues around the set to provide some narrative hooks – the novelist’s beautiful old mechanical typewriter with a page inserted (titled “The Shadow over Dunwich”, a combination of two of his story titles that directly
reference each other – early draft, or a reminder to us not to look for any single source for the story?), scattered notes, books, postcards pinned to walls, pendants, ornaments, bric-a-brac… some were used by the cast, others were there for the audience. At times it was difficult not to wonder whether you were reading too much into something – deliberate visual clue or mannerism/accident? At one point the novelist or narrator sat at his typewriter desk, one trouser leg up, the other down. Are we being told that Lovecraft was a Freemason? In TSOI, the Esoteric Order of Dagon replaced Freemasonry in Innsmouth, and took over the local Masonic Hall… or did actor Jake Harders just catch the cloth against the chair whilst sitting down?
And then there was the music. That music that had sounded so dissonant and cacophonous in the open environs of the school gym… now it was incredible. Obviously, it was still a dissonant cacophony, but in its correct setting and context, it carried the story along. It provided the auditory cues to cast and audience alike, just at the periphery of hearing, suggesting the ebb and flow of tides, storms, cascades, rain on cobbles, creaking doors, distant shuffling, muttering and globby gibbering, the Gaussian hiss of the chaos hinted at in the interstellar gulf (I’m getting carried away here). The audience’s sense of oppressive malignancy was heightened, the music articulating their latent feelings of unrest and menace as they watched the players’ descent into madness and horror. The music also served to bracket and carry the dance moves or sequences, which might otherwise have looked somewhat stilted, although they too looked totally different than they had at the dress rehearsal, thanks in part to the excellent use of light and shadow.
Acting, dance, music and stage sets all came together to create the intangible weird horror that is Lovecraft’s Innsmouth… all that was absent was the pervasive smell of fish.
I’m not going to write about the plotline or story, as that was essentially for the audience to deduce or interpret as the performance unfolded. I will, however, write about the characterisations, which included some very nice touches. Jake Harders played the narrator/novelist, who we can assume is Lovecraft, although his introduction and epilogue indicate that he may also represent the protagonist in TSOI, Robert Olmstead. David Cox played a part which according to my rehearsal notes was described as “The Detective”, but also seemed based on Olmstead, the architecture-obsessed narrator of TSOI. There’s a scene where the two meet, circling each other and mirroring each other’s movements, before Cox cries out “Who are you? WHO ARE YOU?” A case of creation facing his creator?
Robb Wildash played a seaman, who, along with Cox’s detective, falls for the wiles of Kaz Brown’s tempting seductress, one of the Deep Ones, an elder race of half ichthyic/half batrachian “fish-like frogs or frog-like fishes” with human posture, if not gait, trying to lure them away from the dock and onto the black reef and the cyclopean city that lies deep below in the abyss (my interpretation).
In a wonderful piece of casting, Amy Karen Watterston took the role of a mad old lady, wandering the streets of Innsmouth muttering about the hideous secrets in the town. While the detective and the mariner are descending into madness, she’s already there. Snaith has made an inspired scripting decision in choosing t
o switch Zadok Allen’s homeless alcoholic tramp for an insane crone. It balances the gender mix of the ensemble, and makes for a more plausible plot (what self-respecting deity would be mollified by the sacrifice of a drunken hobo?). Haydn Davis was the cultist, or High Priest of the Esoteric Order of Dagon, who tracks down the mumbling old lady to both silence her, and to offer her as sacrifice to Father Dagon and the Great Old Ones. Davis must have had a ball with this role, hamming it up (and I use those words in the nicest possible way) in his makeup and cowled robe, putting me in mind of the caped villain in those old black and white silent films, tying the maiden to the railroad tracks…
And whilst on the subject of makeup, I can’t end this review without mentioning the sterling work of designer Suzie Demarco, responsible for makeup and prosthetics. Here’s a wonderful montage of her original design for the Deep One princess, set against a photo I took of Kaz Brown in her latex face mask and skullcap. From concept to execution with barely a change!
So, onto my verdict – I loved it, although “love” probably isn’t the right word – it was more like the frisson of joy and terror I used to get watching Doctor Who as a child from behind the sofa, but more visceral. Victoria Snaith and Dread Falls Theatre struck just the right balance of revelation and suggestion in creating this thought-provoking and eerie show. Just as I had struggled through the maze of black drapes catching glimpses of the cast as they flitted from set to set, I felt that the veil of reality had been lifted, just for a split second, onto the hideous desolate vistas of alien places.
I’m going to give this production 4 stars, and am only holding the last one back, as I heard that DFT made some changes and and alterations in later performance that increased the audience participation and interaction with the cast. This was billed as a “preview show”, so I am hoping that a full series of performances will follow. If so, I’ll be there; if not, I’ll be scanning the media for future spine-tingling Dread Falls Theatre productions!
The ensemble cast: L-R: Haydn Davis, Jake Harders, Kaz Brown, David Cox, Amy Karen Watterston, Robb Wildash, director Victoria Snaith

















































































Album Cover Photograph ©Keith Morris

